Sections

Weather Forecast

Close
Advertisement

UND nickname struggle intensifies

Email Sign up for Breaking News Alerts
Detroit Lakes, 56501
Detroit Lakes Minnesota 511 Washington Avenue 56501

GRAND FORKS - Take the single most offensive racial epithet in American English, add "Prairie" to it and you have what may be the most offensive thing anyone can call a Prairie Indian.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Those words appear in bold, three-quarter-inch type on fliers that are now spreading all over the Spirit Lake reservation.

They're part of a quote opponents of UND's Fighting Sioux nickname and logo are alleging the late Ralph Engelstad spoke a dozen years ago in a bar, when referring to Sioux Indians trying to change the nickname of the hockey team he once played on.

Today, those trying to make that change are using the fliers as part of a campaign to convince voters on the reservation to say "no" to a referendum on the nickname and logo Tuesday.

The explicit goal is to demonstrate that Fighting Sioux is connected with racists.

The Herald obtained one of the fliers Thursday at a rally by nickname opponents in Fort Totten, N.D.

The Engelstad family, members of which have seen a picture of the flier, expressed outrage.

"The allegations made against my father by name and logo opponents are the most cowardly and despicable allegations I have ever heard," said Kris Engelstad McGarry in a prepared statement from the Engelstad Family Foundation. "My father cared deeply for the people of North Dakota, and he spoke very fondly of American Indians."

Ralph Engelstad also cared deeply about the nickname and logo, which he used liberally throughout the $100-plus million hockey arena named after him that he built on campus.

One of the rally organizers, Erich Longie, said he's not clear just who produced the fliers, but he doesn't disavow its use.

"Our ancestors faced overwhelming odds throughout their lives; we suffered all kinds of indignities," he said. "Now, we're facing a foundation with millions and millions of dollars and they're coming on the reservation to cause all this turmoil. All we're doing is fighting back."

In other words: All's fair in this asymmetrical war over the nickname and logo.

The referendum is critical for both sides because, under a settlement with the NCAA, UND cannot keep the nickname past Nov. 30, 2010, if it doesn't win the support of both Sioux tribes in North Dakota. If Spirit Lake voters approve the referendum, and some nickname opponents think it has a good shot, it would demonstrate that at least one tribe disagrees with the NCAA that Indian nicknames are derogatory.

The justification

For Longie, it's not whether Engelstad said what the fliers claim -- though he felt the allegation is very plausible -- it's the necessity of such tactics when fighting from a weak position.

Nickname opponents both on the reservation and on campus have complained about the involvement of Ralph Engelstad Arena and the foundation in the nickname referendum. Spirit Lake opponents, Longie among them, say the foundation is pouring thousands of dollars into the pro-nickname campaign that's dividing the tribe, pitting relatives against relatives.

Longie's cousin, Eunice Davidson, in fact, is one of the pro-nickname organizers.

"They're coming onto the reservation; they're causing all kinds of problems, and now, they're complaining," Longie said. "What do they expect?"

"In this instance, being concerned about what Ralph may or may not have said is not the issue," he said. "Court orders, relatives battling relatives. That's what's inflammatory."

Ralph Engelstad Arena, the foundation and Spirit Lake nickname supporters say there is no such funding effort. Davidson said all of the money comes from donations by Spirit Lake tribal members.

At issue for the foundation is the reputation its benefactor.

"I won't stand by while my father's reputation is attacked almost seven years after his death," McGarry said. "He doesn't even have a chance to defend himself."

Not only would Engelstad never use such language, the foundation said, he was very fond of Indians, referencing the time years ago Engelstad donated $33,000 to help the state put a statue of Sakakawea in the nation's capital.

The foundation also criticized the moral relativism seemingly practiced by nickname opponents.

"The hypocrisy of this situation is deplorable," the foundation said in the statement. "Name and logo opponents who claim to be the victims of a human rights violation focus their attention and their efforts on making slanderous allegations against individuals and organizations that are only indirectly associated with the central issue at stake."

Opponents, it said, are using "race-based fear" because they know it's the only way they have a chance of winning.

The context

Without the racial epithet, the quote on the fliers is simply a strongly worded sentiment that the speaker would rather die before letting Indians change the name of his hockey team.

But the epithet radiates a hatred that turns toxic all the words around it.

The alleged speaker is referred to by name and these descriptions: "Known Nazi sympathizer" and "Nazi lover."

In 1986 and 1988, Ralph Engelstad held Adolph Hitler-themed private parties on the genocidal dictator's birthday at his Las Vegas Imperial Palace Hotel and Casino, earning him a $1.5 million fine from Nevada's gaming authorities. He later apologized.

The flier's designer connected Engelstad to the nickname referendum by accusing his foundation of funding the pro-nickname campaign. The foundation and Spirit Lake nickname supporters have denied the allegation, saying all funding came from Spirit Lake donors.

There were other fliers at the Thursday rally that also attempted to hammer home the message that the nickname has racist supporters, though none was as inflammatory as the fliers with the racial epithet.

One flier had two images: one, a Waffen-SS poster and, the other, a grainy photo of German officers meeting with Hitler except one of the officers had the face of Ralph Engelstad digitally pasted on. It evidently came from a Web site opposed to Indian sports mascots.

Another flier had pictures from a 2007 UND sorority party in which some men -- two of them white and one Asian -- wore loincloths, war paint and feathers. A woman wearing an Indian maiden dress appeared to be in the middle of war whoop.

Longie said this one was his best weapon in converting nickname supporters into opponents.

Still another flier had quotes evidently taken from a Facebook group, "Petition to keep the Fighting Sioux nickname." Among the quotes were insults directed at Indians and this one: "Not to sound like a (expletive), but we did win the war. White America was kind enough to not kill them all, so ... yeah, we shouldn't have to give up the name."

Many other quotes from the group, however, merely defend the nickname without insulting Indians.

The origins

It's difficult to convey the impact of the alleged Engelstad quote containing the racial epithet, but the Herald is choosing not to repeat it because the newspaper cannot verify its origin.

Terry Morgan, another anti-nickname organizer, said Friday that opponents had a "signed affidavit" from a witness who allegedly heard the damning quote but that he'd have to find it.

The Herald could not reach him Saturday to see if he found the document.

Morgan said the witness was a white bartender who served two men in 1997. The men said terrible things about Indians in the course of a conversation about the Fighting Sioux nickname. The bartender thought one of the men was Ralph Engelstad and checked with his manager, who verified it was.

Morgan noted that the bartender said he was proud of the nickname until he heard those words.

Jody Hodgson, the general manager of Ralph Engelstad Arena and a representative of the foundation, questioned the timing of the allegation. This quote was spoken 12 years ago, he said, but it is just now emerging in the middle of a contentious political campaign.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
randomness